Everyone has an opinion.
Some say iPhones are overpriced. Others say Androids are built like wet paper towels.
But when it comes to breakage and repair costs, who’s really worse?

We’ve repaired thousands of phones at Barrie Screen Repair — both Apple and Android. So here’s what the actual numbers say.

Let’s Talk Breakage Rates

We hate to say it, but:
iPhones and Androids both break — a lot.

But not equally.

iPhones:

• Sleek design = more screen exposure
• High resale value = people are more likely to fix them than toss them
• Ceramic Shield is tough, but not “drop-on-driveway” tough

Androids:

• Glass builds have increased across brands
• Some models (ahem, Samsung S-series) are just as fragile
• Budget Androids tend to survive drops better… but don’t look great doing it

Our shop data says:
iPhone users break their screens more often,
but Android users are more likely to wait too long to fix it — or not fix it at all due to the high cost.

iPhone vs Android: Screen Repair Costs

Here’s where the two really split.

Why Androids can be more expensive:

• Screens often fused to frame = harder to repair
• Parts less standardized = more variation in pricing
• Fewer quality aftermarket options

So… Which One Costs More Over Time?

iPhones tend to:

• Break slightly more often
• Cost a bit less to repair (surprisingly)
• Have a more consistent repair experience
• Hold value better if fixed quickly

Androids tend to:

• Break less, but when they do — it’s a big bill
• Cost to repair vary wildly by model
• Sometimes aren’t worth fixing at all (especially lower-end models)

If you’re buying with repair in mind, iPhone wins on long-term value.
If you’re buying with durability in mind, get a budget Android and a tank case.

Bonus: Battery Life & Repair Costs

Quick peek at common battery replacements:

• iPhone batteries → $90–$150
• Android batteries → $80–$120 (if available)

Need help deciding if it’s worth fixing? We’ll quote both and let you decide.

Need a quote for either? We fix both. →

Common iPhone & Android Fixes We Handle:

• Cracked screens
• Charging ports that need to be angled just right
• Batteries that die at 40%
• No power / no display
• Water damage (especially after “just a little rain”)

Related Posts:

• How Long Do iPhone Screens Really Last? Experts Weigh In
• iPhone Screen Not Working? 5 Fast Fixes Before You Panic
• iPhone Repair in Barrie: Your Options Explained

TL;DR

• iPhones break more but are cheaper to fix
• Androids break less often, but when they do — yikes
• Either way, we fix it

Request a fast quote now
Or stop by and show us your cracked screen — we’ve seen worse.