There’s this moment everyone with a broken phone faces:

You drop it.
The screen shatters.
You whisper a prayer and flip it over.
And there it is — a spiderweb of heartbreak staring back at you.

Cue internal debate:
“Do I fix this thing… or finally upgrade?”

Let’s be honest: phones are expensive, confusing, and unnecessarily fragile.
But replacing your entire device every time something breaks? That’s a wallet-emptying hobby.

So let’s break it down. The real math. No fluff. No tech snobbery. Just the truth.

---

📉 What Does It Cost to Fix?

Here’s what you’re typically looking at at Barrie Screen Repair:

🔧 Screen Repairs:

• iPhone 11 → $100–$120+tax
• iPhone 12/13 → $120–$240+tax
• iPhone 14 → $130-300+tax
• Android? Depends on the model, but we’ll quote it fast.

🔋 Battery Replacements:

• Most iPhones → $80–$130
• Usually done in under two hours
• Your phone feels like new after (seriously)

Pro tip: If you’re dealing with both battery + screen damage, you can often get a package deal. Just ask us.

---

💸 What Does a New Phone Cost?

Here’s where the math gets spicy:

• iPhone 15 Pro = $1,699+
• Samsung S24 Ultra = $1,999 (!!!)
• Even a “budget” phone is $400–$700
• Plus tax. Plus accessories. Plus setup. Plus probably a new case because the old one “doesn’t fit.”

Also: say goodbye to your photos, passwords, home screen vibe, and mental stability for a few days.

---

⚠️ When You Think You’re Ready to Upgrade But…

Let’s say you’ve decided to go all in on a new phone.

Cool. But ask yourself:

• Does your carrier require a 2-year contract with your soul?
• Is your current phone actually fine except for the one thing?
• Is this upgrade solving a real problem — or just shiny object syndrome?

We’re not here to shame you. We’re just saying…
Sometimes $160 for a new screen saves you from spending $1,600 you didn’t need to.

---

Here’s the Real Math

Let’s say your iPhone 12 screen is cracked.

• You fix it for $210+tax with an apply quality screen.
• It lasts another 1–2 years.
• You just bought 700 days of phone life for $0.30/day.

Meanwhile, a new phone is $1,500+ with no headphone jack, no charger in the box, and no explanation for why Face ID stops working when you lie down.

---

📲 If Your Phone Meets These Criteria — FIX IT:

✅ The phone still works fine
✅ It’s under 5 years old
✅ The screen or battery is the only real problem
✅ You don’t need the newest camera to photograph your lunch

---

If Your Phone Looks Like This — REPLACE IT:

❌ Cracked screen + broken back + dying battery + your apps stutter like it’s 2014
❌ It’s been waterlogged and smells faintly of lake
❌ You’re embarrassed to pull it out in public
❌ You already borrowed your friend’s phone to Google this post

---

🧠 Related:

Still unsure? Here’s what we charge to fix screens:
👉 The Real Cost of Fixing a Cracked iPhone Screen in Barrie

---

🎯 TL;DR

Fix your phone if:

• It’s still a good phone
• You only broke one part
• You’d rather keep your money

Replace your phone if:

• It’s held together by tape and prayer
• Your camera app opens with a 6-second delay
• You’re already halfway through a contract and want out

---

📲 Need help deciding? Contact us for a fast, honest quote

We’ll tell you straight — even if it means not taking your money.
(But also, we’re really good at fixing things.)